Ian McFadyen

All posts tagged Ian McFadyen

Ian McFadyen: Paedophiles need help, not exclusion

Published November 25, 2014 by misty534

Screen Shot 2014-11-25 at 16.45.06

IF anyone should have no time and no sympathy for someone who harbours vile thoughts of abusing a child for sexual kicks, then it’s me.

My life was destroyed after being abused as a schoolboy by my teachers. I ended up taking drugs. My career, relationship and emotional state all disintegrated. I became homeless and adrift.

So coming face to face with someone who represents everything that is to blame for my shattered life – a self-confessed paedophile – could have tipped me over the edge.

Some people might find it strange, then, that I’m now calling for greater understanding and support for those whose darkest fantasies involve society’s most vulnerable.

I’d like to see money and effort poured into helping them in their fight against the demons that drive them to want to abuse. That probably sounds unusual coming from someone who was abused by a paedophile ring of teachers while I was a schoolboy at Nick Clegg’s old school, Caldicott Preparatory School in 
Buckinghamshire. I now firmly believe we need a radical change in the way we deal with the problem.

At first I felt I couldn’t bring myself to take part in the Channel 4 programme, The Paedophile Next Door, which explores radical solutions and theories aimed at supporting people with dangerous predilections towards society’s young innocents.

The producers invited me to meet a self-confessed paedophile – though one who had not offended – to discuss what drives his unsavoury feelings towards children as young as five. Had it been suggested to me when I was at my lowest ebb, I might well have been driven to physical assault. Then I realised that as abnormal as it seemed, this guy was doing something ground-breaking – he was admitting what he was thinking and trying to get help before he did something he didn’t want to do.

The trouble is, offenders who end up behind bars can be left without proper help and instead can go on to forge links with other paedophiles which simply compounds the problem once they are released.

To help break the chain, I believe we need a radical rethink of the UK’s approach to child sex offenders with the emphasis on opening up an early route for potential offenders to discuss their thoughts and feelings openly without fear of possible prosecution or being ostracised.

We have to accept that there is a large group of people out there who are attracted to children and who communicate with each other using the internet.

They may not want to offend, but they are in a group which supports each other. They can be infiltrated by sex offenders who argue that it’s OK to feel this way, that it’s natural and the looking at images is not really harming a child.

The programme by award-winning documentary maker Steve Humphries suggests a more sympathetic response so they can be encouraged to seek help before they are tempted to offend.

I believe that chasing paedophiles underground doesn’t work. If someone comes out saying they can’t help how they feel and they need help, then that has to be better than waiting for something awful to happen.

But the offences are so abhorrent that they are hard to debate. The usual reaction is “hang them high, castrate them, send them to an island somewhere”. The reality is that today’s laws don’t work.

Offering support to paedophiles doesn’t suggest an acceptance of what they do. If you have a paedophile in your community with the potential to offend and they get support and don’t do it, then it must be better than them going on to harm a child.

At the end of the day, I want children to be safe.

The Paedophile Next Door is on Channel 4 tonight at 9pm

Edinburgh Evening News

The Paedophile Next Door: Expert says ‘preventing paedophilia is like working with an addiction’

Published November 25, 2014 by misty534

Dr Sarah Goode estimates 250,000 men in the UK could have sexual feelings for children – but believes prevention is a better option than prison

Screen Shot 2014-11-25 at 15.36.51


A contributor to Channel 4 documentary The Paedophile Next Doorhas told how men who might be inclined to abuse children need support before they offend.

Dr Sarah Goode, an expert on the subject of paedophilia, estimates 250,000 men in the UK could have sexual feelings for children – but believes prevention is a better option than prison.

Appearing on This Morning, Dr Goode told Phillip Schofield and Amanda Holden that those men who had sexual feelings towards children but were determined not to act on them could be helped through support groups which work in a similar way to addiction therapy.

Dr Sarah Goode: ‘We’ve got an epidemic of child sexual abuse at the moment’

Noting that paedophilia cannot be ‘switched off’, Dr Goode said: “It is a little bit like working with an addiction.

“So it is thinking about coping strategies, it is giving that person support and challenging their behaviour so it is really keeping them in a group of people – so it is like ongoing therapy.”

She added: “I certainly believe in prison for offenders, absolutely.

“We’ve got an epidemic of child sexual abuse at the moment and nobody knows how to respond and how to keep children safer.

“My suggestion is we need to go a little bit further upstream than we’ve been doing and be working with people before they offend.”

Ian McFadyen, who was repeatedly raped by his teacher in the 1970s and who comes face-to-face with a self-confessed paedophiles in the documentary, said he understood criticism of such an approach as being “soft”.

“What I want to make clear is I don’t want to normalise paedophilia,” he said.

“I am no advocate for paedophiles. I hold very strong opinions about people who abuse children so it was not an easy decision to be involved in this process.

“But what has become apparent is all of our child protection procedures are reactive, they’re after the event has occurred – the abuse has occurred to the children.

“Very little proactive work is being done, to stop children from being hurt, to eliminate the abuse.”

Rob Leigh

Abuse survivors threaten to boycott government’s inquiry

Published November 6, 2014 by misty534

A group of child abuse survivors tell MPs that, unless Home Secretary Theresa May replaces the entire panel she has appointed to oversee the inquiry, they will boycott the whole process.

Watch Video     http://bcove.me/u0rz5hsx

They discussed their concerns over the setting up of the inquiry with the chair of the Commons home affairs select committee Keith Vaz. The meeting came after the resignation of the second person due to chair the probe last week.

Ian McFadyen, who survived sexual abuse as a schoolboy, described the meeting as a step in the right direction, but added that only a High Court judge could now be trusted to be impartial and that the inquiry needed statutory powers.

He said that, with the appointments of former chairs Baroness Butler-Sloss and Fiona Woolf, survivors had “all been told that this is it, accept it and get on with it”. He insisted that survivors were not just being unreasonable, and trying to scuttle the process: “This is an inquiry into establishment cover-up and, possibly, going to the heart of government.

“They have the best of intentions, I’m sure, but politicians’ fingers need to be away from this. For it to be impartial, they need to not have any involvement,” he told Channel 4 News.

Screen Shot 2014-11-06 at 22.30.36

Andi Lavery, another survivor of abuse as a schoolboy, told Channel 4 News “it was unanimous in the room, we will not co-operate with the inquiry in any shape or form” unless the panel changes.


On Monday, Theresa May was forced to go to the House of Commons to apologise after Fiona Woolf became the second person she appointed to lead the inquiry to resign. Ms Woolf’s departure followed that of Baroness Butler-Sloss four months ago, who also resigned over her links with establishment figures.

Fiona Woolf had been under pressure to reveal her links to former Home Secretary Leon Brittan, who is expected to feature in the inquiry, for weeks before she finally stood down.

But Mr McFadyen said that some survivors – including him – would have been able to accept her as chair if she had been up front about her background.

‘Led down the garden path’

“They needed someone to come forward and say ‘these are my connections, this is what I have to disclose and there is nothing else to hide’ before taking the job. It is not her associations that are the problem, it is the due diligence,” he said, while acknowledging that he could not speak for all survivors.

He said that so far, here had been little transparency or consultation from the government over the selection of the panel and the chair. Many survivors, he said, “feel they are being led down the garden path by the Home Office”.

Mr McFadyen said that some survivors would not be happy with a judge leading the inquiry and acknowledged that one would be unlikely to have no links to the establishment. But he said that engaging with survivors openly over those links could smooth the process.

“I am not naïve about it but I need to get some level of impartiality,” he said. And he added that, in order to achieve that, survivors themselves should not sit on the inquiry’s panel.